🔒Licensed and insured — ask for proof before work begins
⏱Response time under 30 minutes for emergency lockouts
💰Transparent pricing — gives a total quote over the phone, not just a "starting at" number
⭐Strong review history — 4+ stars with enough reviews to be credible

New York is a higher-cost market, so expect locksmith prices above the national average. That said, a premium price should come with premium service — fast response, clear communication, and no hidden fees. The locksmiths ranked above have all earned strong reviews from New York residents.

Typical New York Locksmith Prices

Adjusted for local cost of living

ServicePrice Range

House Lockout$135–$300

Car Lockout$65–$195

Lock Rekey$65–$169

Lock Replacement$130–$390

Full Pricing Guide →

Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about the best locksmiths in New York.

Who is the best locksmith in New York?

Based on our weighted ranking of rating and review volume, Top Notch Locksmith & Security is the top-rated locksmith in New York with a 4.9-star rating and 1309 reviews. See the full ranking above for more options.

How much does a locksmith cost in New York?

In New York, a house lockout typically costs $135–$300, with an average of around $210. Car lockouts run $65–$195. Prices vary by time of day, lock type, and complexity.

Are these locksmiths available 24/7?

Many of the top-rated locksmiths in New York offer 24/7 emergency services, though hours vary by provider. Check each locksmith's profile for their current hours. For after-hours calls, expect a surcharge of $25–$75 on top of regular rates.

See all 76 locksmiths in New York

See all 76 locksmiths in New York →